Spreading an asset's cost across the years it serves β an accounting fiction with very real tax consequences.
π Where this lives: Depreciation is the reason a profitable company can pay little tax quite legally. Governments know this and use it deliberately: accelerated depreciation allowances are among the most common industrial policy instruments in the world, because letting a firm write off a new machine faster is an immediate cash incentive to buy the machine. Nepal's Income Tax Act does exactly this through its pooled declining-balance system. Search "accelerated depreciation tax incentive capital investment policy".
What depreciation is, and the straight line method
D_SL = (C β S)/n D_DB = B Γ (2/n) With C = 1000 Rs 000, S = 100 Rs 000, n = 5 years, SL = 180 Rs 000, DB1 = 400 Rs 000, ratio = 2.22 Γ.
Declining balance writes off roughly twice as much in the first year as straight line does. Same asset, same life, same total β only the timing differs, which is why the choice of method changes reported profit and tax in the early years without changing the economics.
DEPRECIATION IS THE SYSTEMATIC ALLOCATION OF AN ASSET'S COST
OVER ITS USEFUL LIFE.
THE FIRST THING TO BE CLEAR ABOUT β and it is examined:
DEPRECIATION IS NOT A CASH FLOW. NO MONEY MOVES WHEN AN
ASSET IS DEPRECIATED.
The cash left when the machine was bought. Depreciation merely
records, year by year, how much of that spending is treated as
an expense of each year's operations.
WHY IT IS DONE AT ALL β three distinct purposes, often confused:
1. MATCHING (accounting). An asset earns revenue over several
years, so charging its whole cost to the year of purchase
would understate that year's profit and overstate every
later year's.
2. TAX (the reason that matters financially). Depreciation is
a DEDUCTIBLE EXPENSE, so it reduces taxable income and
therefore reduces tax paid. THAT TAX REDUCTION IS A REAL
CASH SAVING β the DEPRECIATION TAX SHIELD.
3. REPLACEMENT PLANNING β tracking book value indicates when
an asset is nearing the end of its economic life.
THE CAUSES OF DEPRECIATION:
PHYSICAL β wear, corrosion, fatigue, accidental damage
FUNCTIONAL β obsolescence, inadequacy for grown demand,
a change in requirements
NOTE THAT OBSOLESCENCE OFTEN DOMINATES: a five-year-old
server may be in perfect physical condition and still
worthless, which is why computing equipment is depreciated
far faster than a building.
THE TERMS:
P or C first cost (purchase + installation + commissioning)
S salvage (residual) value at the end of life
n useful life in years
Dβ depreciation charge in year t
BVβ BOOK VALUE at end of year t = C β (accumulated
depreciation)
DEPRECIABLE BASE = C β S, the amount to be written off.
NOTE THAT BOOK VALUE IS NOT MARKET VALUE. Book value is an
accounting construct following a formula; market value is what
someone will pay. They coincide only by accident.
ββ STRAIGHT LINE METHOD (SLM) ββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
The simplest and most widely used:
D = (C β S) / n the same every year
BVβ = C β tΒ·D
WORKED: C = 500,000, S = 50,000, n = 5.
D = (500,000 β 50,000)/5 = Rs 90,000 per year
YEAR DEPRECIATION BOOK VALUE
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
0 β 500,000
1 90,000 410,000
2 90,000 320,000
3 90,000 230,000
4 90,000 140,000
5 90,000 50,000 β equals salvage β
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
ADVANTAGES: simple, predictable, easy to audit.
DISADVANTAGE: IT DOES NOT MATCH REALITY. Most assets lose
value fastest in their early years β a vehicle loses a large
fraction of its value the moment it is driven away β and
straight line depreciation charges the same amount in year 5
as in year 1.
The accelerated methods, and Nepal's system
ACCELERATED METHODS CHARGE MORE DEPRECIATION EARLY AND LESS
LATER. They match the real pattern of value loss better, and β the
practical reason they are chosen β THEY DEFER TAX, which is
valuable because a rupee of tax paid later is worth less than one
paid now.
ββ SUM OF YEARS DIGITS (SYD) βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
SYD = n(n + 1)/2
Dβ = (C β S) Γ (n β t + 1) / SYD
For n = 5: SYD = 5(6)/2 = 15, and the fractions run
5/15, 4/15, 3/15, 2/15, 1/15.
YEAR FRACTION DEPRECIATION BOOK VALUE
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
1 5/15 150,000 350,000
2 4/15 120,000 230,000
3 3/15 90,000 140,000
4 2/15 60,000 80,000
5 1/15 30,000 50,000 β salvage β
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
YEAR 1 CHARGES 150,000 AGAINST STRAIGHT LINE'S 90,000 β 67%
more β while year 5 charges only a third as much. The total
written off is identical at 450,000; ONLY THE TIMING DIFFERS,
AND TIMING IS WORTH MONEY.
ββ DECLINING BALANCE (DB) ββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
Dβ = BVβββ Γ d, where d is a fixed rate
DOUBLE DECLINING BALANCE (DDB) uses d = 2/n
THE ESSENTIAL DIFFERENCE FROM THE OTHER TWO: THE RATE IS
APPLIED TO THE BOOK VALUE, NOT TO (C β S). SALVAGE VALUE DOES
NOT ENTER THE FORMULA AT ALL β it enters only as a FLOOR
below which book value may not fall.
WORKED, same asset, d = 2/5 = 0.40:
YEAR CALCULATION DEPRECIATION BOOK VALUE
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
1 500,000 Γ 0.40 200,000 300,000
2 300,000 Γ 0.40 120,000 180,000
3 180,000 Γ 0.40 72,000 108,000
4 108,000 Γ 0.40 43,200 64,800
5 64,800 Γ 0.40 = 25,920
BUT that would give BV = 38,880 < salvage 50,000,
SO THE CHARGE IS LIMITED TO 14,800 50,000
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
total written off: 450,000 = C β S β
YEAR 5 SHOWS THE RULE THAT EXAMS TEST: DEPRECIATION STOPS AT
THE SALVAGE VALUE. Applying 0.40 mechanically would have
written the asset below its residual worth, so the final
charge is truncated to exactly what remains.
NOTE ALSO THAT PURE DECLINING BALANCE NEVER REACHES ZERO β
a fixed percentage of a shrinking number is always positive
β which is why a switch to straight line, or truncation as
here, is always needed.
ββ COMPARISON OF THE THREE βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
YEAR SLM SYD DDB
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
1 90,000 150,000 200,000
2 90,000 120,000 120,000
3 90,000 90,000 72,000
4 90,000 60,000 43,200
5 90,000 30,000 14,800
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
total 450,000 450,000 450,000
EVERY METHOD WRITES OFF THE SAME TOTAL. The choice affects
only WHEN the deduction is taken β and because of the time
value of money, EARLIER IS WORTH MORE. DDB's year-1 charge is
more than double straight line's.
ββ THE TAX EFFECT, which is the point ββββββββββββββββββββββ
AFTER-TAX CASH FLOW = (revenue β cash expenses β depreciation)
Γ (1 β tax rate) + depreciation
Equivalently, and more revealingly:
after-tax cash flow
= (revenue β cash expenses)(1 β t) + (depreciation Γ t)
THE SECOND TERM IS THE DEPRECIATION TAX SHIELD: depreciation
multiplied by the tax rate. At a 25% tax rate, a 200,000
depreciation charge saves 50,000 in tax β REAL CASH, in that
year.
THIS IS WHY ACCELERATED DEPRECIATION IS VALUABLE and why
governments offer it as an investment incentive: it moves
the tax shield earlier, raising its present value without
changing the total tax eventually paid.
ββ DEPRECIATION IN NEPAL βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
The Income Tax Act 2058 (2002) uses a POOLED DECLINING BALANCE
SYSTEM rather than depreciating each asset individually.
Assets are grouped into classes, each with its own rate,
broadly:
CLASS A β buildings, structures: LOW rate
CLASS B β office equipment, furniture
CLASS C β vehicles and heavy plant
CLASS D β general plant and machinery
CLASS E β intangibles, amortised over their legal life
Additions during the year enter the pool and disposals leave
it, with depreciation applied to the pool's closing balance.
SPECIAL INDUSTRIES β manufacturing, hydropower β receive
ADDITIONAL ALLOWANCES (commonly a further third of the
normal rate), which is industrial policy expressed through
the tax code.
ALWAYS CHECK CURRENT RATES against the Finance Act of the
year, since they are revised in the annual budget.
NOTE THE DIFFERENCE FROM THE TEXTBOOK METHODS: WITH POOLING,
NO INDIVIDUAL ASSET HAS A BOOK VALUE β only the pool does.
That is administratively far simpler and is why most modern
tax systems have moved to it.
Every method writes off the same Rs 450,000. The choice changes only when the deduction is taken β and because of the time value of money, earlier is worth more. That is why accelerated depreciation is a real incentive to invest despite changing the total tax eventually paid by nothing at all.
π Go further: The gap between book value and market value is where the accounting fiction becomes visible. A fully depreciated machine has a book value of zero β or of its nominal salvage β yet may run productively for another decade and sell for a substantial sum; conversely a three-year-old server carried at half its cost may be genuinely unsellable. Because the depreciation schedule follows a formula chosen years earlier rather than any observation of the asset, the two numbers coincide only by coincidence. Anyone reading a balance sheet needs to know that "net book value" is a record of a calculation, not an estimate of worth. Search "book value versus market value fully depreciated assets".
π‘ Exam angle: state clearly that depreciation is not a cash flow but affects cash flow through tax. Produce full schedules for all three methods on a given asset β SLM D = (CβS)/n, SYD with fractions (nβt+1)/[n(n+1)/2], and DDB at d = 2/n applied to book value. The two details examiners check are that DDB ignores salvage in the formula but treats it as a floor, and that all methods write off the same total. Give the after-tax cash flow formula and identify the depreciation tax shield = depreciation Γ tax rate. Mention that Nepal's Income Tax Act 2058 uses pooled declining balance by asset class.